The Accuracy Gap: Where Automatic Captions Can Fall Short

Published February 29, 2024

Automatic captioning represents a crucial advancement in digital accessibility. This technology employs advanced algorithms and machine learning to transcribe spoken words into text, displaying them in real-time on-screen. The significance of this technology is profound; it bridges communication gaps and ensures multimedia content is inclusive and accessible to all.

However, despite its significant contributions to inclusive media, automatic captioning has limitations. While the technology has made remarkable progress, it remains susceptible to inaccuracies, which can lead to viewer frustration and exclusion. This article will explore the challenges of automatic captioning and discuss strategies content creators can implement to address these issues.

The current state of automatic captioning

Automatic captioning technology employs sophisticated AI algorithms to transcribe spoken language into text rapidly. These systems begin by analyzing audio signals and segmenting speech into smaller, manageable parts. Speech recognition algorithms then convert these segments into written words, considering context and language structure. Advanced models are increasingly adept at recognizing nuances in speech, such as tone and accent.

Automatic captioning has become a ubiquitous feature across a diverse array of digital platforms. Video streaming services like YouTube use automatic captions to make content more accessible. Social media platforms, including Facebook and Instagram, have also adopted this feature, broadening the reach of video posts. Conferencing tools like Zoom also offer real-time captioning, which is vital for inclusivity in virtual meetings.

These services are constantly evolving. While they are becoming more accurate and efficient, certain challenges persist.

Where automatic captions fall short

Despite the advancements in automatic captioning, it has its shortcomings. A primary concern is its susceptibility to inaccuracies, which are often more pronounced than those in manual captioning. For instance, a study by the University of Minnesota found that only 60-70% of YouTube’s automatic captions are accurate. That means that 1 in 3 automatically captioned words could be incorrect. While humorous, this video from McMaster University demonstrates the barrier to understanding that faulty auto-captions can cause.

These inaccuracies significantly impact users with audio impairments who depend on captions for comprehension. Misinterpretations due to incorrect captions can lead to misinformation and feelings of exclusion. Furthermore, caption errors, such as incorrect homophones or missing punctuation, can disrupt the flow of information. This not only makes the content less enjoyable but also more challenging to follow for all viewers. This raises the question: what are the root causes of these inaccuracies in automatic captioning?

Complex Terminology

Automatic captioning systems often encounter challenges with complex terminology, particularly in technical, medical, or industry-specific contexts. As a result, captions may need to be more accurate and notice crucial jargon, leading to inaccuracies that significantly affect comprehension.

Such inaccuracies can obstruct learning in educational settings, especially for students with audio impairments or who otherwise rely on captions to participate. For professionals who use these tools during webinars, meetings, or training videos, inaccuracies in captioning can cause misunderstandings, decrease productivity, and isolate users based on their abilities. 

Diverse Accents and Dialects: A Major Hurdle

Diverse accents and dialects pose a significant challenge for automatic captioning systems. These systems are often trained primarily on standard dialects, leading to difficulties with variations in pronunciation, rhythm, and intonation characteristic of regional or international accents

In video content, a Scottish accent may be transcribed less accurately than an American accent. Automated captioning systems can also misinterpret colloquialisms and localized speech patterns prevalent in regional dialects.

For captions to be effective, they must achieve 99% accuracy. Such pitfalls present significant obstacles to meeting this standard of accuracy and inclusivity, underscoring the need for further advancements in captioning technology. 

How to ensure accuracy

Ensuring accuracy in automatic captions involves a range of best practices. Foremost is the need for high-quality audio free of grammatical errors, mispronunciations, and background noise. Integrating a custom vocabulary list into the captioning system can significantly improve accuracy, especially for content rich in specialized jargon, such as recorded lectures or instructional videos.

However, human oversight is the most crucial element in this process. Like most accessibility tools and technology, there are some indispensable human touches that automation can’t ever replicate. While automated captions may be a good place to start, a human reviewer's nuanced understanding and contextual judgment serve as a vital checkpoint to correct errors that automated systems overlook.

Incorporating human checkers, regular testing, and user feedback creates a vital feedback loop for continuous improvement. Prioritizing these strategies makes digital content more accessible and inclusive, enhancing the viewing experience for all audiences.


Automatic captioning greatly improves digital accessibility, but accuracy challenges are encountered, especially with complex terminology and diverse accents. Research has highlighted these limitations, which particularly affect viewers with audio impairments. Custom vocabulary lists and high-quality audio are best practices for specialized content.

However, human oversight is the most crucial factor in enhancing caption accuracy. It provides the nuanced understanding and contextual judgment that automated systems alone cannot achieve. Prioritizing such strategies ensures an equitable viewing experience for all audiences, a critical consideration in our increasingly digital world.

Watch on-demand's event on Closed Captioning here.

Vendor Directory offers the premier impartial listing of digital accessibility vendors.  Search for products and services by category, subcategory, or company name.  Check out our new Vendor Directory here.